I argue that genre fiction seems to be enjoying an acceptance that didn’t exist a decade ago. Writers like Lev Grossman, Jonathan Lethem, Colson Whitehead, Heidi Julavits, Justin Cronin, Tom Perrotta are all blurring the line. Chabon disagrees.
“You think it’s changing?” Chabon asks Díaz.
“I don’t think it’s changed at all, I think it’s worse,” Díaz says, before turning to me. “Name to me a genre writer who’s won a Guggenheim,” he says. “Name to me a genre writer who’s won a National Book Award.”
“Well, they gave that lifetime [award] to Stephen King, and that caused this huge fuss,” Chabon says.
“We seem to think that things are changing because the people with privilege dabble across the board,” says Díaz, growing more animated. “I’ve noticed that genre fiction writers are more isolated than they’ve ever been. I think that they’re less likely to win any prizes. Listen, we’ll talk about Justin Cronin all day, and I could trot out 12 other novelists who’ve been writing zombie novels, but because they’re genre writers, they’re not going to get a f–king profile inThe New York Times.
“We’re willing to talk about how one side is benefitting, how one side is taking these experiments, but this other side has been doing this for so long, and nobody wants to give them any love,” he continues. “I’m sorry, I don’t give a f–k what the f–k my side of the equation is doing. … It doesn’t stop us from getting MacArthurs. I want somebody who’s writing theFantastic Four to get a MacArthur, get a Guggenheim.”